The Top 10 Worst “Community” Fish
Published November 15, 2011
A list of common community fish that are aggressive, sensitive or require special treatment.
There are no such thing as bad fish, just owners who have not done proper research before purchasing them. “Community” tanks can be constructed in a variety of ways, it just depends on what kind of community you want. For example, Lake Malawi cichlids, when kept in the appropriate water parameters and in the correct set up, can create an active and interesting social community. This is also true for aggressive fish such as the red-tailed black shark, or shy and sensitive fish like celestial danios. The key is to read up on the conditions that a fish will prefer before buying it. There are a few ideas to consider when building a community, such as diet, social preferences and water conditions, and then you can simply find fish with similar requirements.
Realistically, most people want a bright and active tank with many different types of fish in it, and will just walk down the “community” isle of the local fish store picking out favorites. If this is your technique, here is a list of common community choices that are not well suited for a standard community tank because they require special water conditions in order to survive, they are extremely sensitive to water quality, they are subjected to inhumane practices or are just generally difficult to keep alive and happy. For a list of fish that grow too big for a standard tank, please see “Top 10 worst tank busters”.
The 10 worst community fish are:
10. Plecos
I actually really like plecostomus catfishes, and in full disclosure my very first community fish was a pleco, but there are still some major drawbacks to keeping them. Common varieties can grow to be a foot long and they produce massive amounts of waste and even smaller ones can still manufacture disproportionate levels of poop. You can basically double the bio-load of your community tank by adding one of these guys. And in addition to that, some plecos don’t consume very much algae and may preferentially shred plants and driftwood.
9. Glass catfish
These little guys look like they could add visual interest to any community aquarium because of their uncommon appearance. Their bodies are transparent so that you can see right through their skin and muscle to their bones – quite a striking sight! This would make for a fascinating addition to your aquarium – that is, if you ever saw them. The are terribly shy, and require medium sized shoals (7-10 fish) in order to be even remotely comfortable, but even then, the entire group will probably spend most of their time hiding behind your decorations, plants and filter inlet. And of course, since these fish are clear and colorless, they are nearly impossible to spot. Unless you have a refined appreciation for subtlety in your aquarium, you should look for a bolder substitute. Additionally, they are very fragile fish, and can perish easily both from instable water conditions and from bodily injury.
8. “Fancy” guppies
Fancy guppies are extremely appealing for a community tank because they are friendly, small and come in a range of brilliant colors and striking patters. Unfortunately, most guppies can barely survive the trip home from the pet store. Decades of selective breeding has resulted in stocks that are inbred and weak, and males seem to fair particularly poorly. There are alternatives however – “feeder” guppies can actually be quite pretty, and if you allow them to breed for several generations visually appealing traits often intensify. If you choose to bring home feeder fish however, quarantine them before introducing them to your community tank as they may harbor diseases.
7. Angelfish
While these fish can make graceful and elegant centerpieces in a tank, they are not well suited for a community atmosphere. Angelfish, a species of cichlid, are aggressive to their own species and need to be kept in breeding pairs or in large groups. Keeping them in small groups will allow for the strongest to bully the weakest fish, sometimes to death. As they get larger, they may pick off smaller fish for food. They also prefer specialized conditions in order to thrive. They are sensitive to water quality, and need a slightly acidic pH (6.5-7), low hardness and a warm temperature (~80F). Additionally, the long fins of these fish make the irresistible to common community species such as the black skirt tetra who will chase and nip them. Once they reach their adult size, these fish require lots of space too.
The 10 worst community fish are:
10. Plecos
I actually really like plecostomus catfishes, and in full disclosure my very first community fish was a pleco, but there are still some major drawbacks to keeping them. Common varieties can grow to be a foot long and they produce massive amounts of waste and even smaller ones can still manufacture disproportionate levels of poop. You can basically double the bio-load of your community tank by adding one of these guys. And in addition to that, some plecos don’t consume very much algae and may preferentially shred plants and driftwood.
9. Glass catfish
These little guys look like they could add visual interest to any community aquarium because of their uncommon appearance. Their bodies are transparent so that you can see right through their skin and muscle to their bones – quite a striking sight! This would make for a fascinating addition to your aquarium – that is, if you ever saw them. The are terribly shy, and require medium sized shoals (7-10 fish) in order to be even remotely comfortable, but even then, the entire group will probably spend most of their time hiding behind your decorations, plants and filter inlet. And of course, since these fish are clear and colorless, they are nearly impossible to spot. Unless you have a refined appreciation for subtlety in your aquarium, you should look for a bolder substitute. Additionally, they are very fragile fish, and can perish easily both from instable water conditions and from bodily injury.
8. “Fancy” guppies
Fancy guppies are extremely appealing for a community tank because they are friendly, small and come in a range of brilliant colors and striking patters. Unfortunately, most guppies can barely survive the trip home from the pet store. Decades of selective breeding has resulted in stocks that are inbred and weak, and males seem to fair particularly poorly. There are alternatives however – “feeder” guppies can actually be quite pretty, and if you allow them to breed for several generations visually appealing traits often intensify. If you choose to bring home feeder fish however, quarantine them before introducing them to your community tank as they may harbor diseases.
7. Angelfish
While these fish can make graceful and elegant centerpieces in a tank, they are not well suited for a community atmosphere. Angelfish, a species of cichlid, are aggressive to their own species and need to be kept in breeding pairs or in large groups. Keeping them in small groups will allow for the strongest to bully the weakest fish, sometimes to death. As they get larger, they may pick off smaller fish for food. They also prefer specialized conditions in order to thrive. They are sensitive to water quality, and need a slightly acidic pH (6.5-7), low hardness and a warm temperature (~80F). Additionally, the long fins of these fish make the irresistible to common community species such as the black skirt tetra who will chase and nip them. Once they reach their adult size, these fish require lots of space too.
6. Discus
These fish, like angel fish, are beloved for their bright colors and interesting personalities. Also like angelfish, they require special water parameters – soft, stable, slow moving and warm water. They are shy around other species of fish, and can be easily outcompeted for food. They actually will do best when kept in species-specific tanks with lots of space to swim around in and a calm environment in which to interact with conspecifics.
5. Dye injected fish
This trend has fortunately been loosing popularity in recent years, although many people still buy dyed fish because they have brilliant colors or unique patterns. Common examples are glassfish that have been painted with bright dyes or cichlids with “tattoos”. Dying living animals is inhumane and cruel – not to mention that the look is tacky and eventually wears off (if the fish survives the procedure). Note: Florescent colored zebrafish are not dyed, although they may appear to be. These fish (Glofish) are actually the descendents of genetically altered fish that were created for scientific research, and have not been exposed to inhumane treatment.
4. Dwarf gouramis
Gouramis are elegant, beautiful fish that when kept with proper tank mates can be an excellent component of a community tank. However, gouramis of the dwarf variety, usually colored powder blue, royal blue or red, can cause huge problems. These little Napoleons can be quite aggressive, and males often bully each other (as well as everyone else). Additionally, dwarf gouramis frequently carry diseases that can quickly kill other fish. If you are looking for an alternative, keep pearl or honey gouramis (in groups, with 2 females to every male) and be sure to avoid the chocolate gouramis (too sensitive) and larger species like kissing gouramis (too aggressive).
3. Goldfish
Though they are a common “beginner” fish that frequently end up in bowls, tiny tanks or just mixed in with other fish, goldfish are not suited for community tanks for a variety of reasons. This is a group of fish that have been neglected and misunderstood for decades. They require cold water with no heater and their high oxygen requirements make them incompatible with most other fish (and make the standard goldfish bowl completely out of the question!) They also grow quite large, so if you would like to keep goldfish, place them in an outdoor pond.
2. Freshwater eels
Eels are inappropriate for community aquariums for a variety of reasons. Many species grow to be over a foot (some exceed several feet) and they are a nuisance to care for. Eels are esteemed escape artists, and love to climb into filters or slip up and out onto the floor. Many species are also sensitive to water quality, and they require special substrates that will prevent them from scraping and damaging their skin. Some species are also very shy and easily frightened, preferring to burrow into the sand to stay out of sight. Additionally, they can be difficult to feed, many species prefer live food and will eat (or try to eat) their tank mates.
1. Any species of mormyrid
The two most common representatives of the mormyrid group are elephant fish and baby whales, although several other species from this family are occasionally sold. Mormyrids are inappropriate for your community tank for three reasons. First, they are extremely sensitive fish and typically need to be kept by an experienced aquarist in order to thrive. They are “scaleless” and can easily injure themselves on rocks or wood allowing them to develop a skin infection, however they cannot be treated with most antibiotics. Second, the most common species (Gnathonemus petersii) are territorial and can be quite aggressive. While they cannot cause substantial injuries in their tank mates (their mouths are very small), they may harass them to death. Third, they are all wild caught. No successful captive breeding programs exist for mormyrids, and the process of catching, shipping and distributing them results in the deaths of large quantities of these fish. As with any wild caught fish, they may also be difficult to feed because they are accustomed to hunting and catching native prey. This may result in them starving to death because they are out competed by their tank mates or simply unwilling to eat the food that they are provided with. An additional caveat to this is that they are nocturnal, so their food must be available at night.
These fish, like angel fish, are beloved for their bright colors and interesting personalities. Also like angelfish, they require special water parameters – soft, stable, slow moving and warm water. They are shy around other species of fish, and can be easily outcompeted for food. They actually will do best when kept in species-specific tanks with lots of space to swim around in and a calm environment in which to interact with conspecifics.
5. Dye injected fish
This trend has fortunately been loosing popularity in recent years, although many people still buy dyed fish because they have brilliant colors or unique patterns. Common examples are glassfish that have been painted with bright dyes or cichlids with “tattoos”. Dying living animals is inhumane and cruel – not to mention that the look is tacky and eventually wears off (if the fish survives the procedure). Note: Florescent colored zebrafish are not dyed, although they may appear to be. These fish (Glofish) are actually the descendents of genetically altered fish that were created for scientific research, and have not been exposed to inhumane treatment.
4. Dwarf gouramis
Gouramis are elegant, beautiful fish that when kept with proper tank mates can be an excellent component of a community tank. However, gouramis of the dwarf variety, usually colored powder blue, royal blue or red, can cause huge problems. These little Napoleons can be quite aggressive, and males often bully each other (as well as everyone else). Additionally, dwarf gouramis frequently carry diseases that can quickly kill other fish. If you are looking for an alternative, keep pearl or honey gouramis (in groups, with 2 females to every male) and be sure to avoid the chocolate gouramis (too sensitive) and larger species like kissing gouramis (too aggressive).
3. Goldfish
Though they are a common “beginner” fish that frequently end up in bowls, tiny tanks or just mixed in with other fish, goldfish are not suited for community tanks for a variety of reasons. This is a group of fish that have been neglected and misunderstood for decades. They require cold water with no heater and their high oxygen requirements make them incompatible with most other fish (and make the standard goldfish bowl completely out of the question!) They also grow quite large, so if you would like to keep goldfish, place them in an outdoor pond.
2. Freshwater eels
Eels are inappropriate for community aquariums for a variety of reasons. Many species grow to be over a foot (some exceed several feet) and they are a nuisance to care for. Eels are esteemed escape artists, and love to climb into filters or slip up and out onto the floor. Many species are also sensitive to water quality, and they require special substrates that will prevent them from scraping and damaging their skin. Some species are also very shy and easily frightened, preferring to burrow into the sand to stay out of sight. Additionally, they can be difficult to feed, many species prefer live food and will eat (or try to eat) their tank mates.
1. Any species of mormyrid
The two most common representatives of the mormyrid group are elephant fish and baby whales, although several other species from this family are occasionally sold. Mormyrids are inappropriate for your community tank for three reasons. First, they are extremely sensitive fish and typically need to be kept by an experienced aquarist in order to thrive. They are “scaleless” and can easily injure themselves on rocks or wood allowing them to develop a skin infection, however they cannot be treated with most antibiotics. Second, the most common species (Gnathonemus petersii) are territorial and can be quite aggressive. While they cannot cause substantial injuries in their tank mates (their mouths are very small), they may harass them to death. Third, they are all wild caught. No successful captive breeding programs exist for mormyrids, and the process of catching, shipping and distributing them results in the deaths of large quantities of these fish. As with any wild caught fish, they may also be difficult to feed because they are accustomed to hunting and catching native prey. This may result in them starving to death because they are out competed by their tank mates or simply unwilling to eat the food that they are provided with. An additional caveat to this is that they are nocturnal, so their food must be available at night.
A word about brackish fish…
Many fish in this category are sold as freshwater community fish, but this is simply a fallacy. Bumblebee gobies are a common example - they very tiny and calm, making them appear to be an excellent component to a community tank. However they require salt to be added to their water, and if these fish are kept in a freshwater environment they will fail to thrive and eventually (or quickly) die. This is also true for the less common species of “freshwater fish” including dragon gobies, monos (which also get to be 10 inches), archers and scats as well as small flounders and many puffer species.
Many fish in this category are sold as freshwater community fish, but this is simply a fallacy. Bumblebee gobies are a common example - they very tiny and calm, making them appear to be an excellent component to a community tank. However they require salt to be added to their water, and if these fish are kept in a freshwater environment they will fail to thrive and eventually (or quickly) die. This is also true for the less common species of “freshwater fish” including dragon gobies, monos (which also get to be 10 inches), archers and scats as well as small flounders and many puffer species.
There are plenty of fish that are available for a general community tank which are hardy, friendly and attractive. If you find one of the fish on this list to be irresistible, research the conditions and tank mates that are recommended before making a purchase.
[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file /home/schoolre/public_html/srn_lib_shared_LIVE/view/ArticleSocialButtonsView.inc.php on line 45: file_get_contents(https://graph.facebook.com/comments/?ids=): failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! HTTP/1.0 400 Bad Request
The Top 10 Worst Tank Busters
Find out which fish will rapidly outgrow your tank, and the smaller alternatives that are available.
The Basics of Freshwater Fish Compatibility
Whether you are new to the aquarium hobby or not, there are a few things you should know about freshwater fish compatibility. If you do not understand the basics, you may have trouble maintaining a healthy community tank environment.
Most Recent Articles:
-
Aquatic Mosses for Freshwater Tanks
If you like the idea of a planted tank but aren't ready to take on the extra work load, start off small with some aquatic mosses. -
Wavemakers for Saltwater Tanks
If you want to keep your saltwater tank healthy, you need to consider the ideal level of water flow. Installing a wavemaker in your tank will help you strike the right balance. -
Choosing the Correct Temperature for a Marine Aquarium
One of the most important things you must to do ensure the health of your marine tank is to achieve and maintain the ideal temperature. - More articles: General Aquarium Articles, Freshwater Aquarium Articles, Saltwater Aquarium Articles, Miscellaneous Aquarium Articles, Product Reviews (Freshwater)
