Choosing a Freshwater Aquarium Substrate

Published March 06, 2008 - RSS/XML Feed

By Robert Lashlee

The substrate you choose can have a significant impact on the aesthetic look of your tank as well as the health of your fish and live plants. There are four important aspects of the substrate that you should take into account when selecting which is right for you: particle size, color, reactivity with the water, and its effect on your fish.

Particle Size

Substrates vary widely in terms of particle size – everything from sands consisting of very tiny particles to larger river rocks. Large particle substrates allow more uneaten food and waste to penetrate into it leading to toxic build ups if not cleaned. Small particle substrates can compact which may lead to areas that lack oxygen. These areas can eventually release hydrogen sulfide – a substance that is extremely toxic to fish.

The size of the particles also has a big impact on the health of the fish and the ease of cleaning. For instance, some fish like to scoop the substrate in their mouth and move it around. It is not a good idea to mix these species with sand because the small particles can irritate them. Sand can also be somewhat difficult to clean as the small particles often get vacuumed out of the tank along with the waste. On the other hand, some fish enjoy making nests or homes out of the substrate and in these instances, large particle sizes would not be conducive to this habit. As you can see, it is important to research the specific needs of your fish when considering the appropriate particle size.

Color

The color of the substrate is a very personal choice. Many people love seeing bright pink gravel while others would cringe at the thought of such an unnatural looking substrate. One common use of a substrate’s color is to enhance the color of the fish. Darker colors tend to make a light-colored fish look brilliant. On the other hand, a light-colored substrate can wash these same fish out, but can also make dark-colored fish stand out.

Overly dark substrate can reduce how large the tank looks in a similar fashion to painting a room in your house a dark color. For this reason, some people use lighter colored substrate to make the aquarium feel more open and bright.

You may also want to consider how the substrate will look once it becomes dirty. Brownish-colored substrate tends to hide fish waste more than white substrate, for instance.

Reactivity with Water

Some species of fish require certain water parameters. For instance, many African cichlids prefer a higher pH. One way to raise the pH in your aquarium is to use a substrate that buffers the water (for example, crushed coral). This is why you see so many African cichlid tanks that use crushed coral as their substrate. Peat moss, on the other hand, has the exact opposite effect – it lowers the pH. This is good for fish species such as angelfish.

Impact on Fish

It is important to consider how the substrate you choose will impact your fish. Not only can it react with the water as discussed above, but it can also harm your fish if, for instance, you choose glass chips with sharp edges as your substrate. Also, very light-colored substrate can sometimes spook your fish, especially when it is combined with bright lighting. This may cause them to hide and dull their color. Overall, you should read about the natural habitat and behavior of your fish. Then you can find a good balance between what is pleasing to your eye and what it pleasing to your fish.

Specific Substrate Choices

Now that we have discussed how to pick your substrate in general, we will look at some of the more common substrates.

Bare-bottomed

While this may not be the most beautiful choice, it does serve a purpose. Many breeding tanks, hospital tanks, and tanks used to raise fry use a bare bottom. It makes it easy to catch fish, it is easy to tear down, and it is very easy to clean. However, an obvious con is that there is nothing to hide the waste and uneaten food. It can also be stressful to fish that are used to digging.

Gravel

Gravel is by far the most common substrate used in the hobby. It comes in a multitude of colors and is often favored by young children for this very reason. It also comes in various particles sizes. Larger gravel sizes can allow a great deal of waste to penetrate it making it difficult to keep the aquarium clean. This is one reason why many aquarists prefer smaller-grained gravel. It is also important to not purchase gravel with sharp edges, especially if you have fish that dig or sift the substrate.

Sand

Sand is a very beautiful substrate. There are many types of sand that can be used – everything from play sand to black Tahitian Moon sand. The lightly colored sand really sparkles in an aquarium and sand in general gives a very smooth look to your aquarium. Fish with delicate barbells (such as corydoras catfish) also prefer sand.

Sand also has several aspects that can make it a difficult substrate to work with. The most glaring problem is that it usually has very fine particle sizes. It is often so fine that you will end up siphoning a good deal of it up with your water when you vacuum your tank. This problem can be solved in one of two ways. First, you can simply replace the sand over time. Second, the debris will tend to sit on top of the sand due to its small particle size. You can, therefore, siphon the waste off the top of the sand by holding your siphon a couple of inches above the surface of the sand (although you should disturb the sand slightly so it does not become anaerobic and black).

You need to be careful with your filter choice if you choose sand. If you disturb the bottom too much and fling sand all over your tank, particles of sand can become trapped in the filter. Be cautious when cleaning or rearranging your tank for this reason. Also, under gravel filters generally cannot be used with sand.

The other problem (and ironically, the property of sand that makes it so beautiful) is that it is typically light-colored. Dirt and waste really show up in light-colored sand. Anyone who has ever seen a sand-bottomed tank that has not been vacuumed in a while can attest to this.

Sand is also susceptible to compacting. This makes it a poor choice for a planted aquarium as the roots can have a difficult time penetrating this compacted substrate. If you do decide to mix plants and sand (again, not recommended), then at least carefully mix up the sand every once in a while to prevent compacting.

Crushed Coral

As discussed above, crushed coral raises the pH in the aquarium. Therefore, it is not a good choice for fish that prefer water with a low to neutral pH. It is perfect, however, for fish such as African cichlids. It also gives a salt water “feel” to a fresh water aquarium. If you need the buffering that crushed coral provides, but your fish prefer sand, you can use coral sand as your substrate.

One major problem with crushed coral relates to its light coloration which again does not hide dirt and debris. This can be remedied by frequent vacuuming.

What if you Have Plants?

This is a topic unto itself. Refer to the article list on www.ratemyfishtank.com and read the article regarding choosing a substrate for your planted aquarium.

Conclusion

It is important to thoroughly research the needs of your fish so a substrate that matches their requirements, but still looks pleasant to you, can be chosen. Referencing this article will allow you to consider the important points associated with the selection of your aquarium’s substrate and lead you towards a choice that you and your fish can enjoy for years.

Further Reading

For additional information, refer to the following web pages:

● http://www.calgaryaquariumsociety.com/Articles/A_Question_Of_Substrate.html

● http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substrate_(aquarium)

● http://animal-world.com/encyclo/fresh/plants/PlantSubstrates.htm

● http://www.thatfishshop.com/equipment/substrate.htm

Read Related Freshwater Aquarium Articles

All About Tropical Fish Tanks: An overview of tropical fish tanks, what they are, and the pros/cons of keeping one.
Planted Aquariums: An overview of the different styles of planted aquariums. Different types of plants you could use. Popular plants.
Choosing a Planted Aquarium Substrate: Learn about the factors you should consider when choosing a substrate for your planted aquarium.
Setting up a Freshwater Fish Tank: Information on choosing a fish tank and how to set-one up!
Choosing the Right Filtration System for Your Aquarium: Learn about the different types of filters for your freshwater aquarium.
Properly Aerating Your Aquarium: Learn the basics of aeration and how to properly aerate your aquarium.
Adding Rocks and Wood to Your Freshwater Aquarium: Learn about the things you should consider when adding rocks and wood to your aquarium.
Aquarium Decorations: Types of decorations. Tips on decorating your tank. Online sources
Heating Your Freshwater Aquarium: Learn about different heater options for your fish tank.
The Process of Cycling a Fish Tank: What is "cycling" your fish tank? Why is it important? Instructions for how to do-it.
Freshwater Fishless Cycling: Learn about new methods for cycling your freshwater aquarium without fish.
What Are Good Freshwater Fish For Beginners: What makes a freshwater fish a good candidate for beginners?
Stocking Fresh Water Fish Tanks: Learn how to select the right quantity and combination of fish for your freshwater aquarium.
Acclimating Fish - Drip Method: Learn how to properly acclimate your fish to your aquarium using the drip method.
Properly Maintaining the pH in a Freshwater Aquarium: Learn how about pH and how to properly maintain it in a freshwater aquarium.
The Natural Environments of African and South American Cichlids: Learn about and how to recreate the natural environments of African and South American Cichlids
Cichlid Aggression - How to Reduce Aggression: Learn about the causes of cichlid aggression and methods for reducing it.
Common Freshwater Tropical Fish Diseases: Learn about common fish illnesses and how to effectively treat them.
Breeding Freshwater Fish: Learn how to succesfully breed freshwater fish.
Breeding Mouth Brooding African Cichlids: Learn how to succesfully breed mouth brooding African Cichlids.
Controlling Algae Growth: Learn why algae grows in your tank and how to control it.
Using Carbon in a Freshwater Aquarium: Learn about the differing points of view and guidelines on using carbon in your aquarium.
Fish Tank Maintenance and Cleaning: Tips and instructions for maintaining a healthy fish tank.
Choosing and Conditioning the Water in Your Aquarium: Learn about how to properly choose and condition the water you use in your freshwater aquarium.
Water Testing in Your Freshwater Aquarium: How to test your aquarium's water, and what to look for.
Keeping Goldfish: Advice on keeping Goldfish.
Fish Bowls: An overview of keeping fish in a fish bowl. A brief history. Pros and cons.
Wall Mounted Fish Tanks: Advantages and disadvantages to a Wall Mounted Fish Tank. Installation. Accessories.
Freshwater Fish Article Database: Articles on dozens of different freshwater fish and appropriate care.
Freshwater Plant Article Database: Articles on different freshwater plants and appropriate care.