Rate My Fish Tank - Fish Tank Pictures & Articles
Tetra

Questions? Check our  Forums!

Rate My Fish Tank Forum Index - Freshwater / Planted Tank Discussion - undergravel filter - Reply


 platipus12321


Joined: 31 Jan 2008 GMT
Posts: 22
Contact User Send Message

 

Post Mon Feb 04, 2008 8:07 pm GMT   Reply      

I was wondering how fine of a sand can you have without it ruining the filter? Is even worth the extra money?



 Mattallica87


Joined: 17 Jan 2008 GMT
Posts: 42
Contact User Send Message

View user's profile

 

Post Mon Feb 04, 2008 10:36 pm GMT   Reply      

Not worth it at all. Sand and under gravel don't go hand in hand. Depending on the size of your tank, undertank filters and hang ons should be fine!

Hope this helps



 Peterkarig


Joined: 23 Oct 2007 GMT
Posts: 1492
Contact User Send Message

View user's profile

 

Post Mon Feb 04, 2008 11:01 pm GMT   Reply      

If you get coarse sand that comes from the aquarium store that is coated with plastic and screened to remove the finer particles it should work. I would buy this sand and strain it through a screen over and over with water to remove whatever is left with a hose outside or something, and I would make sure there are no holes in the edges of the UG filter as well. If there are any holes in the edges of your filter it will get clogged. I know it can work because I've done it in my aquariums. The slits are small enough to keep the coarse sifted sand out and it's always the cracks in the edges and underneath the edges of the plates where the sand can get in. Where I've had problems is when I've moved the riser tubes around too much in order to get a big power-head to fit and it lifted up the back edges of the filter plates which let sand get in. It was very hard to get the filter plates to sit back down after I lifted them up, so start by making the plates sit perfectly flat (I would set up the filter plates on a flat table to see if there are no holes) and it should work. Sand will get clogged with debris faster than gravel so you'll have to clean it with a siphon type gravel cleaner more often, and buy a large siphon because the smaller ones just suck the sand up making it harder to do. Use your judgement on this. Like I've said, it's worked with me, but I can't guarantee it'll work for you. I would have at least 3 inches of sand so the weight can hold the filter plates down better, and I've had to pump water backwards down the riser tube sometimes to get the flow going again. Metallica's suggestion may be better in the long run because it is a bit of a pain and is probably esier to just run more filtration elswhere.Good luck!


Rate My Fish Tank Forum Index - Freshwater / Planted Tank Discussion - undergravel filter - Reply

Copyright 2003- RateMyFishTank.com. All rights reserved.